Monday, September 21, 2009

Budgetary control

Budgetary control

There are two types of control, namely budgetary and financial. This chapter concentrates on budgetary control only. This is because financial control was covered in detail in chapters one and two. Budgetary control is defined by the Institute of Cost and Management Accountants (CIMA) as:

"The establishment of budgets relating the responsibilities of executives to the requirements of a policy, and the continuous comparison of actual with budgeted results, either to secure by individual action the objective of that policy, or to provide a basis for its revision".

Chapter objectives

This chapter is intended to provide:

· An indication and explanation of the importance of budgetary control in marketing as a key marketing control technique

· An overview of the advantages and disadvantages of budgeting

· An introduction to the methods for preparing budgets

· An appreciation of the uses of budgets.

Structure of the chapter

Of all business activities, budgeting is one of the most important and, therefore, requires detailed attention. The chapter looks at the concept of responsibility centres, and the advantages and disadvantages of budgetary control. It then goes on to look at the detail of budget construction and the use to which budgets can be put. Like all management tools, the chapter highlights the need for detailed information, if the technique is to be used to its fullest advantage.

Budgetary control methods

a) Budget:

· A formal statement of the financial resources set aside for carrying out specific activities in a given period of time.

· It helps to co-ordinate the activities of the organisation.

An example would be an advertising budget or sales force budget.

b) Budgetary control:

· A control technique whereby actual results are compared with budgets.

· Any differences (variances) are made the responsibility of key individuals who can either exercise control action or revise the original budgets.

Budgetary control and responsibility centres;

These enable managers to monitor organisational functions.

A responsibility centre can be defined as any functional unit headed by a manager who is responsible for the activities of that unit.

There are four types of responsibility centres:

a) Revenue centres

Organisational units in which outputs are measured in monetary terms but are not directly compared to input costs.

b) Expense centres

Units where inputs are measured in monetary terms but outputs are not.

c) Profit centres

Where performance is measured by the difference between revenues (outputs) and expenditure (inputs). Inter-departmental sales are often made using "transfer prices".

d) Investment centres

Where outputs are compared with the assets employed in producing them, i.e. ROI.

Advantages of budgeting and budgetary control

There are a number of advantages to budgeting and budgetary control:

· Compels management to think about the future, which is probably the most important feature of a budgetary planning and control system. Forces management to look ahead, to set out detailed plans for achieving the targets for each department, operation and (ideally) each manager, to anticipate and give the organisation purpose and direction.

· Promotes coordination and communication.

· Clearly defines areas of responsibility. Requires managers of budget centres to be made responsible for the achievement of budget targets for the operations under their personal control.

· Provides a basis for performance appraisal (variance analysis). A budget is basically a yardstick against which actual performance is measured and assessed. Control is provided by comparisons of actual results against budget plan. Departures from budget can then be investigated and the reasons for the differences can be divided into controllable and non-controllable factors.

· Enables remedial action to be taken as variances emerge.

· Motivates employees by participating in the setting of budgets.

· Improves the allocation of scarce resources.

· Economises management time by using the management by exception principle.

Problems in budgeting

Whilst budgets may be an essential part of any marketing activity they do have a number of disadvantages, particularly in perception terms.

· Budgets can be seen as pressure devices imposed by management, thus resulting in:

a) bad labour relations
b) inaccurate record-keeping.

· Departmental conflict arises due to:

a) disputes over resource allocation
b) departments blaming each other if targets are not attained.

· It is difficult to reconcile personal/individual and corporate goals.

· Waste may arise as managers adopt the view, "we had better spend it or we will lose it". This is often coupled with "empire building" in order to enhance the prestige of a department.

Responsibility versus controlling, i.e. some costs are under the influence of more than one person, e.g. power costs.

· Managers may overestimate costs so that they will not be blamed in the future should they overspend.

Characteristics of a budget

A good budget is characterised by the following:

· Participation: involve as many people as possible in drawing up a budget.
· Comprehensiveness: embrace the whole organisation.
· Standards: base it on established standards of performance.
· Flexibility: allow for changing circumstances.
· Feedback: constantly monitor performance.
· Analysis of costs and revenues: this can be done on the basis of product lines, departments or cost centres.

Budget organisation and administration:

In organising and administering a budget system the following characteristics may apply:

a) Budget centres: Units responsible for the preparation of budgets. A budget centre may encompass several cost centres.

b) Budget committee: This may consist of senior members of the organisation, e.g. departmental heads and executives (with the managing director as chairman). Every part of the organisation should be represented on the committee, so there should be a representative from sales, production, marketing and so on. Functions of the budget committee include:

· Coordination of the preparation of budgets, including the issue of a manual
· Issuing of timetables for preparation of budgets
· Provision of information to assist budget preparations
· Comparison of actual results with budget and investigation of variances.

c) Budget Officer: Controls the budget administration The job involves:

· liaising between the budget committee and managers responsible for budget preparation
· dealing with budgetary control problems
· ensuring that deadlines are met
· educating people about budgetary control.

d) Budget manual:

This document:

· charts the organization

· details the budget procedures

· contains account codes for items of expenditure and revenue

· timetables the process

· clearly defines the responsibility of persons involved in the budgeting system.

Budget preparation

Firstly, determine the principal budget factor. This is also known as the key budget factor or limiting budget factor and is the factor which will limit the activities of an undertaking. This limits output, e.g. sales, material or labour.

a) Sales budget: this involves a realistic sales forecast. This is prepared in units of each product and also in sales value. Methods of sales forecasting include:

· sales force opinions

· market research

· statistical methods (correlation analysis and examination of trends)

· mathematical models.

In using these techniques consider:

· company's pricing policy

· general economic and political conditions

· changes in the population

· competition

· consumers' income and tastes

· advertising and other sales promotion techniques

· after sales service

· credit terms offered.

b) Production budget: expressed in quantitative terms only and is geared to the sales budget. The production manager's duties include:

· analysis of plant utilization

· work-in-progress budgets.

If requirements exceed capacity he may:

· subcontract

· plan for overtime

· introduce shift work

· hire or buy additional machinery

· The materials purchases budget's both quantitative and financial.

c) Raw materials and purchasing budget:

· The materials usage budget is in quantities.

· The materials purchases budget is both quantitative and financial.

Factors influencing a) and b) include:

· production requirements

· planning stock levels

· storage space

· trends of material prices.

d) Labour budget: is both quantitative and financial. This is influenced by:

· production requirements

· man-hours available

· grades of labour required

· wage rates (union agreements)

· the need for incentives.

e) Cash budget: a cash plan for a defined period of time. It summarises monthly receipts and payments. Hence, it highlights monthly surpluses and deficits of actual cash. Its main uses are:

· to maintain control over a firm's cash requirements, e.g. stock and debtors

· to enable a firm to take precautionary measures and arrange in advance for investment and loan facilities whenever cash surpluses or deficits arises

· to show the feasibility of management's plans in cash terms

· to illustrate the financial impact of changes in management policy, e.g. change of credit terms offered to customers.

Receipts of cash may come from one of the following:

· cash sales

· payments by debtors

· the sale of fixed assets

· the issue of new shares

· the receipt of interest and dividends from investments.

Payments of cash may be for one or more of the following:

· purchase of stocks

· payments of wages or other expenses

· purchase of capital items

· payment of interest, dividends or taxation.

Steps in preparing a cash budget

i) Step 1: set out a pro forma cash budget month by month. Below is a suggested layout.

Month 1

Month 2

Month 3

$

$

$

Cash receipts

Receipts from debtors

Sales of capital items

Loans received

Proceeds from share issues

Any other cash receipts

Cash payments

Payments to creditors

Wages and salaries

Loan repayments

Capital expenditure

Taxation

Dividends

Any other cash expenditure

Receipts less payments

Opening cash balance b/f

W

X

Y

Closing cash balance c/f

X

Y

Z

ii) Step 2: sort out cash receipts from debtors

iii) Step 3: other income

iv) Step 4: sort out cash payments to suppliers

v) Step 5: establish other cash payments in the month

Figure 4.1 shows the composition of a master budget analysis.

Figure 4.1 Composition of a master budget

OPERATING BUDGET

FINANCIAL BUDGET

consists of:-

consists of

Budget P/L acc: get:

Cash budget

Production budget

Balance sheet

Materials budget

Funds statement

Labour budget

Admin. budget

Stocks budget

f) Other budgets:

These include budgets for:

· administration

· research and development

· selling and distribution expenses

· capital expenditures

· working capital (debtors and creditors).

The master budget (figure 4.1) illustrates this. Now attempt exercise 4.1.

Exercise 4.1 Budgeting I

Draw up a cash budget for D. Sithole showing the balance at the end of each month, from the following information provided by her for the six months ended 31 December 19X2.

a) Opening Cash $ 1,200.

19X2

19X3

Sales at $20 per unit

MAR

APR

MAY

JUN

JUL

AUG

SEP

OCT

NOV

DEC

JAN

FEB

260

200

320

290

400

300

350

400

390

400

260

250

Cash is received for sales after 3 months following the sales.

c) Production in units: 240

270

300

320

350

370

380

340

310

260

250

d) Raw materials cost $5/unit. Of this 80% is paid in the month of production and 20% after production.

e) Direct labour costs of $8/unit are payable in the month of production.

f) Variable expenses are $2/unit. Of this 50% is paid in the same month as production and 50% in the month following production.

g) Fixed expenses are $400/month payable each month.

h) Machinery costing $2,000 to be paid for in October 19X2.

i) Will receive a legacy of $ 2,500 in December 19X2.

j) Drawings to be $300/month.

An example

A sugar cane farm in the Lowveld district may devise an operating budget as follows:

· Cultivation

· Irrigation

· Field maintenance

· Harvesting

· Transportation.

With each operation, there will be costs for labour, materials and machinery usage. Therefore, for e.g. harvesting, these may include four resources, namely:

· Labour:

-cutting
-sundry

· Tractors

· Cane trailers

· Implements and sundries.

Having identified cost centres, the next step will be to make a quantitative calculation of the resources to be used, and to further break this down to shorter periods, say, one month or three months. The length of period chosen is important in that the shorter it is, the greater the control that can be exercised by the budget but the greater the expense in preparation of the budget and reporting of any variances.

The quantitative budget for harvesting may be calculated as shown in figure 4.2.

Figure 4.2 Quantitative harvesting budget

Harvesting

1st quarter

2nd quarter

3rd quarter

4th quarter

Labour

Cutting

nil

9,000 tonnes

16,000 tonnes

10,000 tonnes

Sundry

nil

300 man days

450 man days

450 man days

Tractors

nil

630 hours

1,100 hours

700 hours

Cane trailers

nil

9,000 tonnes

16,000 tonnes

10,000 tonnes

Imp, & sundries

nil

9,000 tonnes

16,000 tonnes

10,000 tonnes

Each item is measured in different quantitative units - tonnes of cane, man days etc.-and depends on individual judgement of which is the best unit to use.

Once the budget in quantitative terms has been prepared, unit costs can then be allocated to the individual items to arrive at a budget for harvesting in financial terms as shown in table 4.2.

Charge out costs

In table 4.2 tractors have a unit cost of $7.50 per hour - machines like tractors have a whole range of costs like fuel and oil, repairs and maintenance, driver, licence, road tax and insurance and depreciation. Some of the costs are fixed, e.g. depreciation and insurance, whereas some vary directly with use of the tractor, e.g. fuel and oil. Other costs such as repairs are unpredictable and may be very high or low - an estimated figure based on past experience.

Figure 4.3 Harvesting cost budget

Item harvesting

Unit cost

1st quarter

2nd quarter

3rd quarter

4th quarter

Total

Labour

Cutting

$0.75 per tonne

-

6,750

12,000

7,500

26,250

Sundry

$2.50 per day

-

750

1,125

1,125

3,000

Tractors

$7.50 per hour

-

4,725

8,250

5,250

18,225

Cane Trailers

$0.15 per tonne

-

1,350

2,400

1,500

5,250

Imp. & sundries

$0.25 per tonne

-

2,250

4,000

2,500

8,750

-

$15,825

$27,775

$17,875

$61,475

So, overall operating cost of the tractor for the year may be budgeted as shown in figure 4.4.

If the tractor is used for more than 1,000 hours then there will be an over-recovery on its operational costs and if used for less than 1,000 hours there will be under-recovery, i.e. in the first instance making an internal 'profit' and in the second a 'loss'.

Figure 4.4 Tractor costs

Unit rate

Cost per annum (1,000 hours)

($)

($)

Fixed costs

Depreciation

2,000.00

2,000.00

Licence and insurance

200.00

200.00

Driver

100.00 per month

1,200.00

Repairs

600.00 per annum

600.00

Variable costs

Fuel and oil

2.00 per hour

2,000.00

Maintenance

3.00 per 200 hours

1,500.00

7,500.00

No. of hours used

1,000.00

Cost per hour

7.50

Master budget

The master budget for the sugar cane farm may be as shown in figure 4.5. The budget represents an overall objective for the farm for the whole year ahead, expressed in financial terms.

Table 4.5 Operating budget for sugar cane farm 19X4

1st quarter

2nd quarter

3rd quarter

4th quarter

Total $

Revenue from cane

130,000

250,000

120,000

500,000

Less: Costs

Cultivation

37,261

48,268

42,368

55,416

183,313

Irrigation

7,278

15,297

18,473

11,329

52,377

Field maintenance

4,826

12,923

15,991

7,262

41,002

Harvesting

-

15,825

27,775

17,875

61,475

Transportation

-

14,100

24,750

15,750

54,600

49,365

106,413

129,357

107,632

392,767

Add: Opening valuation

85,800

135,165

112,240

94,260

85,800

135,165

241,578

241,597

201,892

478,567

Less: Closing valuation

135,165

112,240

94,260

90,290

90,290

Net crop cost

-

129,338

147,337

111,602

388,277

Gross surplus

-

66,200

102,663

8,398

111,723

Less: Overheads

5,876

7,361

7,486

5,321

26,044

Net profitless)

(5,876)

(6,699)

95,177

3,077

85,679

Once the operating budget has been prepared, two further budgets can be done, namely:

i. Balance sheet at the end of the year.

ii. Cash flow budget which shows the amount of cash necessary to support the operating budget. It is of great importance that the business has sufficient funds to support the planned operational budget.

Reporting back

During the year the management accountant will prepare statements, as quickly as possible after each operating period, in our example, each quarter, setting out the actual operating costs against the budgeted costs. This statement will calculate the difference between the 'budgeted' and the 'actual' cost, which is called the 'variance'.

There are many ways in which management accounts can be prepared. To continue with our example of harvesting on the sugar cane farm, management accounts at the end of the third quarter can be presented as shown in figure 4.6.

Figure 4.6 Management accounts - actual costs against budget costs Management accounts for sugar cane farm 3rd quarter 19X4

Item Harvesting

3rd quarter

Year to date

Actual

Budget

Variance

Actual

Budget

Variance

Labour

- Cutting

12,200

12,000

(200)

19,060

18,750

(310)

- Sundry

742

1,125

383

1,584

1,875

291

Tractors

9,375

8,250

(1,125)

13,500

12,975

(525)

Cane trailers

1,678

2,400

722

2,505

3,750

1,245

Imp & sundries

4,270

4,000

(270)

6,513

6,250

(263)

28,265

27,775

(490)

43,162

43,600

438

Here, actual harvesting costs for the 3rd quarter are $28,265 against a budget of $27,775 indicating an increase of $490 whilst the cumulative figure for the year to date shows an overall saving of $438. It appears that actual costs are less than budgeted costs, so the harvesting operations are proceeding within the budget set and satisfactory. However, a further look may reveal that this may not be the case. The budget was based on a cane tonnage cut of 16,000 tonnes in the 3rd quarter and a cumulative tonnage of 25,000. If these tonnages have been achieved then the statement will be satisfactory. If the actual production was much higher than budgeted then these costs represent a very considerable saving, even though only a marginal saving is shown by the variance. Similarly, if the actual tonnage was significantly less than budgeted, then what is indicated as a marginal saving in the variance may, in fact, be a considerable overspending.

Price and quantity variances

Just to state that there is a variance on a particular item of expenditure does not really mean a lot. Most costs are composed of two elements - the quantity used and the price per unit. A variance between the actual cost of an item and its budgeted cost may be due to one or both of these factors. Apparent similarity between budgeted and actual costs may hide significant compensating variances between price and usage.

For example, say it is budgeted to take 300 man days at $3.00 per man day - giving a total budgeted cost of $900.00. The actual cost on completion was $875.00, showing a saving of $25.00. Further investigations may reveal that the job took 250 man days at a daily rate of $3.50 - a favourable usage variance but a very unfavourable price variance. Management may therefore need to investigate some significant variances revealed by further analysis, which a comparison of the total costs would not have revealed. Price and usage variances for major items of expense are discussed below.

Labour

The difference between actual labour costs and budgeted or standard labour costs is known as direct wages variance. This variance may arise due to a difference in the amount of labour used or the price per unit of labour, i.e. the wage rate. The direct wages variance can be split into:

i) Wage rate variance: the wage rate was higher or lower than budgeted, e.g. using more unskilled labour, or working overtime at a higher rate.

ii) Labour efficiency variance: arises when the actual time spent on a particular job is higher or lower than the standard labour hours specified, e.g. breakdown of a machine.

Materials

The variance for materials cost could also be split into price and usage elements:

i) Material price variance: arises when the actual unit price is greater or lower than budgeted. Could be due to inflation, discounts, alternative suppliers etc.

ii) Material quantity variance: arises when the actual amount of material used is greater or lower than the amount specified in the budget, e.g. a budgeted fertiliser at 350 kg per hectare may be increased or decreased when the actual fertiliser is applied, giving rise to a usage variance.

Overheads

Again, overhead variance can be split into:

i) Overhead volume variance: where overheads are taken into the cost centres, a production higher or lower than budgeted will cause an over-or under-absorption of overheads.

ii) Overhead expenditure variance: where the actual overhead expenditure is higher or lower than that budgeted for the level of output actually produced.

Calculation of price and usage variances

The price and usage variance are calculated as follows:

Price variance = (budgeted price - actual price) X actual quantity
Usage variance = (budgeted quantity - actual quantity) X budgeted price

Now attempt exercise 4.2.

Exercise 4.2 Computation of labour variances

It was budgeted that it would take 200 man days at $10.00 per day to complete the task costing $2,000.00 when the actual cost was $1,875.00, being 150 man days at $12.50 per day. Calculate:

i) Price variance
ii) Usage variance

Comment briefly on the results of your calculation.

Management action and cost control

Producing information in management accounting form is expensive in terms of the time and effort involved. It will be very wasteful if the information once produced is not put into effective use.

There are five parts to an effective cost control system. These are:

a) preparation of budgets

b) communicating and agreeing budgets with all concerned

c) having an accounting system that will record all actual costs

d) preparing statements that will compare actual costs with budgets, showing any variances and disclosing the reasons for them, and

e) taking any appropriate action based on the analysis of the variances in d) above.

Action(s) that can be taken when a significant variance has been revealed will depend on the nature of the variance itself. Some variances can be identified to a specific department and it is within that department's control to take corrective action. Other variances might prove to be much more difficult, and sometimes impossible, to control.

Variances revealed are historic. They show what happened last month or last quarter and no amount of analysis and discussion can alter that. However, they can be used to influence managerial action in future periods.

Zero base budgeting (ZBB)

After a budgeting system has been in operation for some time, there is a tendency for next year's budget to be justified by reference to the actual levels being achieved at present. In fact this is part of the financial analysis discussed so far, but the proper analysis process takes into account all the changes which should affect the future activities of the company. Even using such an analytical base, some businesses find that historical comparisons, and particularly the current level of constraints on resources, can inhibit really innovative changes in budgets. This can cause a severe handicap for the business because the budget should be the first year of the long range plan. Thus, if changes are not started in the budget period, it will be difficult for the business to make the progress necessary to achieve longer term objectives.

One way of breaking out of this cyclical budgeting problem is to go back to basics and develop the budget from an assumption of no existing resources (that is, a zero base). This means all resources will have to be justified and the chosen way of achieving any specified objectives will have to be compared with the alternatives. For example, in the sales area, the current existing field sales force will be ignored, and the optimum way of achieving the sales objectives in that particular market for the particular goods or services should be developed. This might not include any field sales force, or a different-sized team, and the company then has to plan how to implement this new strategy.

The obvious problem of this zero-base budgeting process is the massive amount of managerial time needed to carry out the exercise. Hence, some companies carry out the full process every five years, but in that year the business can almost grind to a halt. Thus, an alternative way is to look in depth at one area of the business each year on a rolling basis, so that each sector does a zero base budget every five years or so.

Key terms

Budgeting
Budgetary control
Budget preparation
Management action and cost control
Master budget
Price and quantity variance
Responsibility centres
Zero based budgeting

Saturday, August 8, 2009

PDCA CYCLE- Example

Personal Improvement
The PDCA cycle is a valuable process that can be applied to practically anything. In this session, we discuss case related medical student performance, but the PDCA cycle can be used in everything from making a meal to walking your dog. An immediate concern of yours may be improving your study skills.

Example 1: The Student with Poor Grades

Lakshmi is a first-year medical student who has just taken her first set of examinations and is very unhappy with the results.
• What is she trying to accomplish? Lakshmi knows that she needs to improve her studying skills in order to gain a better understanding of the material.

• How will she know that a change is an improvement? Lakshmi considers the most important measure of her study skills to be her exam grades. However, she does not want to risk another exam period just to find out that her skills are still not good. She decides that a better way to measure improvement is by taking old exams.

• What changes can she make that will result in improvement? Lakshmi thinks that she has spent too little time studying. She feels that the best way to improve her study skills is by putting in more hours.
Cycle 1

Plan: Lakshmi decides to add an additional thirty hours per week to her already busy schedule. She resolves that she must socialize less, get up earlier, and stay up later. At the end of the week she will take an old exam to see how she is progressing.

Do: By the end of the week, Lakshmi finds that she was able to add only fifteen hours of studying. When she takes the exam she is dismayed to find that she does no better.

Check: The fifteen extra hours of studying has made Lakshmi feel fatigued. In addition, she finds that her ability to concentrate during those hours is rather limited. She has not exercised all week and has not seen any of her friends. This forced isolation is discouraging her.

Act: Lakshmi knows that there must be another way. She needs to design a better, more efficient way to study that will allow her time to exercise and socialize.
Cycle 2
Plan: Lakshmi contacts all her medical school friends who she knows are doing well yet still have time for outside lives. Many of these friends have similar advice that Lakshmi thinks she can use. Based on her findings, she decides to always attend lectures, to rewrite her class notes in a format she can understand and based on what the professor has emphasized, and to use the assigned text only as a reference.
Do: Lakshmi returns to her original schedule of studying. However, instead of spending a majority of her time poring over the text, she rewrites and studies her notes. She goes to the text only when she does not understand her notes. When Lakshmi takes one of the old exams, she finds that she has done better, but she still sees room for improvement.
Check: Lakshmi now realizes that she had been spending too much time reading unimportant information in the required text. She knows that her new approach works much better, yet she still feels that she needs more studying time. She is unsure what to do, because she doesn't want to take away from her social and physically active life.
Act: Lakshmi decides to continue with her new studying approach while attempting to find time in her busy day to study more.
Cycle 3
Plan: In her search for more time to study, Lakshmi realizes that there are many places that she can combine exercising and socializing with studying. First, she decides to study her rewritten notes while she is exercising on the Stairmaster. Next, she intends to spend part of her socializing time studying with her friends.

Do: Lakshmi's friends are excited about studying together, and their sessions turn into a fun and helpful use of everyone's time. Lakshmi has found that she enjoys studying while she exercises. In fact, she discovers that she remains on the Stairmaster longer when she's reading over her notes. When Lakshmi takes her exams this week, she is happy to find that her grades are significantly higher.

Check: Lakshmi now knows that studying does not mean being locked up in her room reading hundreds of pages of text. She realizes that she can gain a lot by studying in different environments while focusing on the most important points.

Act: Lakshmi chooses to continue with the changes she has made in her studying habits. What Lakshmi initially thought would be an improvement turned out to only discourage her further. Many people who are in Lakshmi's place do not take the time to study their changes and continue them even though they lead down a disheartening path. By using the PDCA cycle, Lakshmi was able to see that her initial change did not work and that she had to find one that would better suit her. With perseverance and the willingness to learn, Lakshmi was able to turn a negative outcome into a positive improvement experience.

Saturday, August 1, 2009

QFD & Target Costing Case Study

BACKGROUND

The company was under contractual obligation to deliver a quick release top nozzle (QRTN) to several customers. This is a complex subassembly costing approximately $1,700 each for a major piece of capital equipment. The current product, a removable top nozzle (RTN), is needed in case a product has to be repaired because of a failure. While this repair is a low probability occurrence, the cost of downtime is very high. If the product can't be repaired within a reasonable period, there are significant operational costs involved.

The current RTN allowed repair within a reasonable time if all things went according to plan. However, there was considerable time and cost involved in mobilizing equipment to support the repair, in setting up the equipment to support the repair, removing and replacing the top nozzle, and tearing down and demobilizing the repair equipment. There were additional problems as follows:

  • The nozzle did not always come free from the product as intended and an additional heavy tool was needed to supply the force to lift the nozzle off.
  • Removal process involved taking out a locking tube, which resulted in a loose part. There was concern that this part could drop during the removal or replacement operation, taking additional time. Competitive designs did not have loose parts.
  • The removal and replacement process was not sufficiently reliable. There was one occurrence when a locking tube was jammed into another locking tube, preventing the assembly from being used.

In order to meet contractual requirements as well as develop a more competitive design for other potential customers, a project was initiated to develop a QRTN. A previous QRTN project was cancelled late in the Detailed Design Phase after the estimated cost increased to a level significantly above the RTN cost (+80%). Additional contractual commitments caused the company to restart the project after several years. A multi-functional core team was created, and a decision was made to use the newly-developed NPD process, target costing, value analysis, and quality function deployment (QFD) to help the team accomplish its objectives. In preparation for this program, hands-on QFD, target costing and value analysis training was provided to team members, several key functional managers, and other potential users of these tools. In addition, a QFD consultant was engaged to help the team apply these tools.

VOICE OF THE CUSTOMER

QFD logically begins with understanding customer needs and using these needs to drive the development process. These customer needs are referred to as "voice of the customer" (VOC). Instead of solely relying on the marketing organization to define these needs, team members met with customers to gain a first-hand understanding of their needs. It was recognized that there were multiple customer voices to consider with this project:

  • Voice of the Customer This is the obvious customer. They need to be satisfied that the QRTN works reliably as intended, both in operation as well as during repair. They also need to be assured that the repair can be done expeditiously, while on the critical path. Understanding this VOC involved a review of contract requirements, discussions with marketing personnel responsible for the accounts that had contractual commitments for the QRTN, and discussions with the customer's engineering personnel. Invitations were issued to two customers to have their personnel participate on the core team, but the customers declined because of the time commitment involved. They did ask to be regularly briefed on the progress.
  • Voice of Services Division The actual reconstitution work was done by the Services Division, a sister division. As a result, they had important insights into the needs to support the actual removal and reinstallation of the top nozzle. A Services Division individual involved in this work was assigned to the core team to provide this insight and support the development process.
  • Voice of the Engineer There are specific regulatory and interface requirements with existing products that must be addressed and considered. Team members familiar with these requirements provided this customer voice.

Prior to meeting with customers, the team obtained a briefing on the prior QRTN effort to familiarize them with some of the issues. Meetings were scheduled with engineering personnel at the customers that had a contractual requirement for the QRTN. The initial meetings were intended to probe and primarily listen for the customer needs. A list of questions to ask and a meeting agenda were prepared to guide these interviews. The teams were briefed on asking "Why" to understand the fundamental customer needs. Several team members were involved in each of these interviews, and they typically talked with multiple people in each customer organization. Interview notes were summarized and distributed to all team members. In addition, these meetings were discussed in detail in subsequent team meetings to assure a complete understanding of each customer's perspectives. Contractual requirements were reviewed. A teleconference with the marketing representatives for the customers was held to gain their perspective.

The customer visits also provided good insight into the design of two of the competitor's products and an in-house design from one of the customers. This proved to be a good opportunity to gather competitive assessment information and provided the information to develop rapid prototyping models and/or sketches of competitive joints.

To gain a better understanding of the voice of Services Division, the team watched a video of the repair process to gain a first-hand understanding of the issues in top nozzle removal and installation. Data was also assembled (Table 1) detailing the time requirements for Services Division to perform its job with the RTN and estimates or goals with the QRTN.

Table 1 - Repair Time Analysis



Activity

Current RTN Design
(3 people required)
Hours

QRTN Design Estimates
(2 people required)
Hours

Equipment Setup

10

2

Repair

10

3

Inspection

1

1

Top Nozzle Removal

2

0.5

Top Nozzle Installation

3

0.5

Post Repair Equipment Tear Down

15

2

Total

41

9

The team met to compile all of the requirements. Brief natural language expressions of customer needs (e.g., "maintain locked joint") were written on "post-its" and placed on the wall. Some questions were asked to clarify meanings and to determine "Why". The team used Affinity Diagramming to organize related statements into logical clusters. Besides organizing the customer needs, this also facilitated the following:

  • Some redundancy in statements of need was observed and eliminated
  • A pattern was observed of some very detailed, lower-level needs mixed with higher-level needs. This led to an attempt to "level" needs by asking "Why" and leading to consolidation with higher level needs.
  • Related needs were discussed to understand the need. This led to the development of a data dictionary.

Initially, there were thirty-three statements of customer needs. By organizing these requirements with affinity diagramming, examining each of these requirements, and asking "why" to understand the fundamental need, this list was consolidated into twelve customer needs. Table 2 shows examples of this consolidation process.

Table 2 - Refining Customer Needs

Original Customer Needs

Consolidated Customer Need

Comment

Thimble rotation resistance

Precludes skeleton damage

No loose parts during joint operation

Joint reliability during repair

By asking "Why", consolidated customer needs back to the basic need.

Simplified tooling

Low cost tooling

Minimize tool mobilization

Minimal removal force

Simple tooling

Consolidated requirements because simple tooling generally would lead to lower cost and cost was not deemed as important a customer need. Couldn't directly control mobilization with the design, but concluded that simple tooling would achieve this same objective. Minimal removal force also related back to simple tooling.

Fast nozzle removal/install

Repair on critical path

No loose parts during joint operation

Minimum number of joints

Maintain alignment during repair

Fast repair

By asking "Why", consolidated customer needs back to the basic need. Many of these lower-level needs then became technical characteristics.

At first, the team did not understand the value of the data dictionary. However, as numerous questions came up over the course of this project, the data dictionary proved invaluable. See the final data dictionary.

PRODUCT PLANNING MATRIX

Once these customer needs were identified, they were organized into a product planning matrix. Based on the initial customer meetings, priorities were assigned to each requirement using a 1 to 5 scale. The information gained on competitive products as well as prior internal competitive assessments was used to look at competing joint designs from a customer perspective and develop an initial Competitive Evaluation. Actual hardware, rapid prototyping models, and sketches were used to support this evaluation. The Competitive Evaluation was done for six joint designs: the current RTN design, the previous QRTN design, a joint company/customer design, a customer design and two competitor's designs. This information was reviewed with customers. They were satisfied with the stated customer needs in the matrix. They provided feedback to make minor changes to priorities and the competitive assessment.

The customer needs, priorities and competitive assessment were reviewed and a product plan was developed. The next step was to develop technical characteristics of the products to respond to customer needs. This was one of the most difficult steps for team members and required a good deal of facilitation and thought. The criteria for the technical characteristics were:

  • Global - must not imply or constrain design alternatives to any one technical solution or approach
  • Meaningful - must be subsequently actionable to drive the design process; they can't be abstract
  • Measurable - must be able to define a target value and clearly determine whether the characteristic has been achieved or not

As these technical characteristics were developed, their definitions were also defined in a data dictionary to assure a common understanding among team members. Again, this was referred to many times during discussions. Examples of the technical characteristics defined in order to satisfy customer needs are shown in Table 3.

Table 3 - Technical Characteristics to Satisfy Customer Needs

Customer Need

Technical Characteristics

Discussion

Visually verify locked joint

Joint verification time

The removal and installation process is done under conditions where the joint can't be directly seen, but is observed via video. It is required to visually verify the joint is locked upon reinstallation. This is videotaped. The nozzle develops a black coating in operation making visual verification difficult. It was observed that the contrast of new parts and having part features that protrude above the surface help with verification. However, stating these as technical characteristics was not global. Therefore joint verification time was determined to be the most appropriate technical characteristic.

Fast repair

No loose parts during operation

Operator lifting force

Joint lock verification time

Maximum removal installation time

Protrusion above adapter plate

OD collet to insert clearance

No moveable tooling parts

A variety of factors support the customer need for fast repair. Loose parts contribute to additional handling time and potential time if part is dropped. If lifting force is greater than what a person can lift, additional equipment and set-up time are required. The two time-related criteria are straight-forward goals. If protrusions exist above adapter plate, additional time is required to lift tool over protrusion to properly seat the tool. The greater the OD collet to insert clearance, the easier it will be to access and pull parts of the product that require replacement. Moveable tooling parts may contribute to additional operation time.

Joint reliability during operation

Minimum joint activation force/torque

Use of approved material

In-operation loose parts simulation/ analysis

The customer need relates to the QRTN joint remaining locked during operation and a concern that small, fine-featured parts may corrode and be broken during operation. The first related technical characteristics establishes a minimum force required to unlock joint to avoid the joint coming unlocked due to dynamic forces during operation. The next two characteristics relate to use of materials and simulation to assure that parts do not corrode or break during operation.

As each technical characteristic was defined, the goal for that characteristic was also established . maximize, minimize, or equal to the target. Next, the relationship to each customer need was established. The relationship defines the degree (strong - weight of 5, medium - weight of 3, or weak - weight of 1) that the technical characteristic satisfies the customer need. It does not define the potential interaction of the characteristic with the customer need. The team often stumbled in this regard; they wanted to define negative interactions between the customer need and the technical characteristic. For example, a number of technical characteristics were seen as having a negative impact on "Minimum price increase" causing the team to want to establish a relationship. Frequent reminders were made that this was not the purpose of this relationship. After the relationships were established, the importance rating of each technical characteristic was calculated.

As technical characteristics were developed, preliminary target values were defined to assure that there was a measurable characteristic. In a few cases, the difficulty in defining a meaningful target value caused the team to redefine the technical characteristic.

The next major step was to define interactions among the technical characteristics. To keep the interactions manageable, the team ignored the minor interactions and even the moderate positive interactions. The strong negative interactions ("N") were of particular importance to manage. Examples of the strong negative interactions are shown in Table 4.

Table 4 - Strong Negative Interactions Examples

Technical Characteristic

Opposing Technical Characteristic

Comment

Target cost

Guide thimble mis-location from true center

To minimize guide thimble mis-location from true center requires tighter tolerances that drive up cost. This potential conflict can addressed with tolerance analysis and careful allocation and management of tolerances.

Inactive joints

Guide thimble stresses

Adapter plate stresses

Joint component stresses

As the number of active joints is reduced, the stresses on all of these components increase. After discussing this issue and considering the potential number of times that an assembly would be reconstituted and joints overridden, it was decided to reduce the target value for inactive joints from 4 to 2.

Protrusion above adapter plate

Joint lock verification time

While the protrusion above the adapter plate needs to be minimized to prevent interference with other components in the customer's system and prevent impacting cooling flow, some protruding features aid in verifying a locked joint and reducing the verification time if the protruding features can be kept below the height of this target value. This potential conflict can be managed through team awareness of the issue.

P>The product planning matrix was finished by establishing target values once the interactions and importance of each technical characteristic was understood and establishing an estimate of technical difficulty for each of these characteristics at the target value. See the final QRTN product planning matrix

The product planning matrix was used to identify areas for follow-up and investigation. For approximately half of the technical characteristics, required follow-up steps or areas of investigation were identified to finalize target values or assess achievement of target values as concept alternatives were explored. Examples are shown in Table 5.

Table 5 - Follow-up Actions

Technical Characteristic

Target Value

Planned Action

Minimum joint activation force / torque

32 in-oz / X lbs

Establish minimum force / torque requirements

Deflection limit under 4g load

0.025 ins.

Investigate basis of 0.025 in. specification

OD collet-to-insert clearance

Zero on nominal stack-up

Review and optimize OD collet tool for max guide thimble clearances

Inactive joints

2 joints

Determine history of failed joints from the Service Division's history

CONCEPT SELECTION

Once the technical characteristics of the QRTN were understood, product design began. The first step was to develop concept alternatives. In order to meet target costs and the defined technical characteristics, creative solutions were needed. This process began with brainstorming. A brainstorming session was scheduled with not only the QRTN team members, but approximately 6 other people that had experience with nozzles and past QRTN efforts. The brainstorming session occurred over a six-hour period. It began with briefing on the product planning matrix and the technical characteristics and design issues that needed to be addressed. A function tree diagram was prepared to focus people's attention on the functions that needed to be prepared rather than starting from the point of existing design concepts.

The group was then divided into teams of three to four people to brainstorm and then develop concept alternatives for the QRTN joint. Each team then presented their concepts to the rest of the group and discussion ensued. The QRTN team then took those concept alternatives and further reviewed and discussed them. The concept alternatives were organized into six families and the most promising concept in each of these families was further discussed and developed by a group of sub-team members.

The team used a concept selection matrix with the technical characteristics as decision criteria to screen these concept alternatives and down-select to four alternatives. An objective of the down-select was to yield two traditional alternatives and two more radical alternatives to carry forward. One of the problems recognized was that the criteria were not "leveled" and, therefore, insufficient weighting was given to target cost. Adjustments to the weightings were needed to address this. Sub-teams then further developed these four alternatives.

The concept selection matrix in conjunction with engineering analysis and development of product cost estimates will be used to select two final design alternatives which will be carried forward to the Preliminary Design Phase. One of the first steps in this phase will be to prepare a deployment matrix to further define critical characteristics of key components.

TARGET COST

In parallel with the effort to gather the voice of the customer, analysis was done to develop a target cost. Marketing was asked how much would customers be willing to spend to obtain a QRTN feature vs. the RTN feature. Marketing agreed that the QRTN feature would be of interest to customers and that they should be willing to pay more for it. However, it became apparent that this feature would more likely be offered to maintain competitiveness at no additional cost or would be folded into overall pricing so that it was not apparent what the price difference would be.

The company provides the product under warranty. When a product requires repair, the company pays the Service Division to perform the repair. Any time savings in performing the repair because of the QRTN would be reflected in lower warranty costs. Data had been gathered in Table 1 showing the planned time savings that a QRTN design would offer over an RTN design. The Service Division representative on the core team provided data on the crew size and labor costs. Data was also collected on the number of repairs performed over a several year period. This was used to determine frequency of occurrence. Based on all of this data, the expected value of warranty savings with a QTRN design was calculated. This was added to the RTN baseline cost to yield the target cost established for this project. This calculation is shown below.

Target Cost = RTN Baseline Cost + Warranty Cost Savings

Warranty Cost Savings = Frequency of Repair Occurrence x QRTN Cost Savings

QRTN Cost Savings = Labor Rate x (RTN Manhours - QRTN Manhours) [See Table 1]

This target cost was included in the Product Planning Matrix as a target value.

Once the work was begun on concept development, the GA SEER DFM software was used to support cost estimating. The model was validated by developing a model of the existing RTN and comparing the model cost estimates with the current RTN costs. A model of the previous QRTN design was also established to validate the model against previous cost estimates. The team was unfamiliar with the cost model and did not appreciate how it could be used to support the process. Meetings were held to discuss this and the model expert was assigned to support the team. He met with the team to define a preliminary parts list and a preliminary process definition (manufacturing process steps or routings) for each alternative. The intent was to develop preliminary cost estimates to support:

  • Refinement of product and process design alternatives to reduce cost
  • Comparison of concept alternatives for selection of the preferred concept(s)

The project was designated as high priority for the Division and established as a "heavy-weight" program with a key functional manager designated as the project manager. The initial staffing consisted of:

  • Project Coordinator
  • Lead Designer
  • Manufacturing Engineer
  • Service Division Representative (part-time)
  • Purchasing Representative (part-time)

Because of the challenges with achieving target cost, two additional manufacturing engineers were assigned to support the team on a part-time basis. In addition, since this was a pilot project, two additional members of the value engineering team participated in the meetings to observe the process and support deploying the process to future programs. One of those individuals was the lead designer on the past QRTN program and became heavily involved with this program, providing briefings and contributing to the discussions and analysis. It soon became apparent that additional designers were going to be required to support the program and this individual along with another part-time designer were formally added to the project team. The other member of the value engineering team was also drafted. It is important to recognize the resource intense commitment that is required to support a wide investigation of alternatives and active manufacturing involvement in the early phase of a program.

This entire process took twenty weeks from the start of training to selection of the final concept alternatives for development. The most time consuming activities were collecting the voice of the customer in the beginning and the preliminary engineering development of the concepts including the cost estimates.

RESULTS

The product is entering the final development and testing phases. Estimated costs at this point are approximately 15% above the RTN cost and 5% above the cost target. However, this is significantly less than the previous QRTN development where costs were estimated at 80% over the RTN costs. As a result, this project is considered a major success and a successful demonstration of QFD and target costing.